Alchemical Hands in the Hypnerotomachia Poliphili

Marginalia, Scholarship & Reception

← Dictionary

Antiquarianism Draft

Scholarly Debates
The systematic study and collection of artifacts from the ancient past, a practice central to the HP's intellectual world.
Griggs (1998) argues that the HP should be understood as the culmination of fifteenth-century Italian antiquarianism rather than as Romantic escapism. The book's verbal and visual strategies derive from Cyriacus of Ancona's commentaria and mid-century antiquarian syllogae (topographically organized manuscript collections of inscriptions and monuments). Poliphilo's journey through architectural ruins enacts the antiquarian mode of knowledge-making.

Why It Matters for the Hypnerotomachia

The HP enacts the antiquarian mode of knowledge-making: Poliphilo encounters ruins, inscriptions, and ancient monuments, and generates understanding through careful observation and recording. The book's verbal and visual strategies derive from the fifteenth-century antiquarian tradition.

Why It Matters in Scholarship

Griggs (1998) argues that the HP should be understood as the culmination of Italian antiquarianism rather than Romantic escapism. The book's strategies derive from Cyriacus of Ancona's commentaria and mid-century manuscript collections of inscriptions and monuments.

Key Passages / Evidence

  • ... II. Leon Battista Alberti, Self-Portrait Medal (c. 1436-8) (National Gallery, Washington, DC). in obelisks, Alberti does not appear to have made a serious effort to test his theory against a... [Word_Image_1998_jan_vol_14_iss_1_2_Curran_Brian_A_The_Hypnerotomachia_Poliphili]
  • ... Poliphilo Hypnerotomachia (p.27) Having examined Poliphilo’s self-transformation from the perspective of narrative thresholds, and the formal and arithmosophical symbolism of... [O'Neill (Durham thesis)]
  • ... the sylloge serves as a guide to a visually accessible antiquity. Marcanova's manuscript opens with an album of 15 pen and ink drawings depicting Roman locations and monuments. Military... [Word_Image_1998_jan_vol_14_iss_1_2_Griggs_Tamara_Promoting_the_past_The_Hypnerot]

Source Documents

Blunt 1937 (HP in French art); Gollnick (Apuleius dreamworld); Lefaivre 1997 (Alberti attribution); O'Neill (Durham thesis); Semler 2006 (Dallington); Word_Image_1998_jan_vol_14_iss_1_2_Bury_John_Chapter_III_of_the_Hypnerotomachia; Word_Image_1998_jan_vol_14_iss_1_2_Curran_Brian_A_The_Hypnerotomachia_Poliphili; Word_Image_1998_jan_vol_14_iss_1_2_Griggs_Tamara_Promoting_the_past_The_Hypnerot; Word_Image_1998_jan_vol_14_iss_1_2_Temple_N_The_Hypnerotomachia_Poliphili_as_a_p

Page references: p. 7, p. 8, p. 124, p. 125, p. 126, p. 127, p. 128, p. 13, p. 14, p. 15, p. 16, p. 5, p. 6, p. 23, p. 24
Sources: Griggs 1998; Curran 1998

Review Status / Provenance

Draft
  • Source method: CORPUS_EXTRACTION
  • Confidence: MEDIUM
  • Notes: Enriched from corpus reading packets on 2026-03-19. 20 passages retrieved from 9 documents.